Is Yesteryear Based on Ballerina Farm?

Quick Answer: No—not exactly. Caro Claire Burke has not said that Yesteryear is a fictionalized version of Hannah Neeleman or Ballerina Farm. However, she has openly acknowledged that the novel was influenced by the broader tradwife movement and that real internet personalities—including Hannah Neeleman—were part of the cultural landscape she studied while writing the book. (British Vogue)

Because of those similarities, many readers naturally assume that Natalie Heller Mills is based on Ballerina Farm. The reality is more nuanced.

In this article, we’ll separate confirmed facts from reader speculation and explain what Caro Claire Burke has actually said about the inspiration behind Yesteryear.

⚠️ Spoiler Warning

This article discusses major plot points from Yesteryear.

If you haven’t finished the novel yet, you may want to read our Yesteryear Review first before continuing.

Why Do Readers Think Yesteryear Is About Ballerina Farm?

The comparison begins almost immediately.

Natalie Heller Mills, the protagonist of Yesteryear, is a hugely successful social media influencer who has built her brand around an idealized vision of traditional family life. She shares farm content, homemade food, faith, motherhood, and a carefully curated image of domestic perfection with millions of followers.

Those details closely resemble the public image of Hannah Neeleman, the influencer behind Ballerina Farm, whose videos and business have made her one of the most recognizable faces associated with the modern tradwife movement. (Wikipedia)

Readers have pointed to several obvious similarities:

• Both women are influential homesteading creators.
• Both present an idyllic rural lifestyle online.
• Both are associated with conversations about traditional gender roles.
• Both inspire strong reactions from supporters and critics alike.
• Both sit at the center of wider debates about authenticity, motherhood, and social media.

Given those parallels, it’s understandable why so many readers immediately connected the fictional Natalie to the real-life Ballerina Farm brand.

What Is Ballerina Farm?

Ballerina Farm is the lifestyle brand created by Hannah Neeleman, a former Juilliard-trained ballerina who now documents life on her family’s Utah farm.

Her content focuses on topics such as:

• Homesteading
• Cooking from scratch
• Raising children
• Farming
• Traditional homemaking
• Rural family life

Over the past few years, Ballerina Farm has become one of the internet’s most recognizable examples of the “tradwife” aesthetic. At the same time, it has also become the subject of widespread debate about gender roles, work, family expectations, and the difference between curated online content and everyday reality. (Wikipedia)

Those public conversations provide important context for understanding Yesteryear.

What Has Caro Claire Burke Said?

This is where the story becomes much clearer.

Rather than identifying one specific inspiration, Burke has repeatedly explained that Yesteryear grew out of her fascination with the broader tradwife phenomenon and the online performance of femininity.

In an interview with British Vogue, she said that while readers may compare Natalie to Hannah Neeleman, she doesn’t know Neeleman personally and instead drew from “a patchwork of influences.” She also mentioned figures such as Nara Smith, The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, and other internet personalities, explaining that many creators present similar versions of idealized womanhood. (British Vogue)

In interviews with Vogue and ELLE, Burke has consistently emphasized that her interest wasn’t in satirizing one individual but in exploring larger questions about internet identity, gender expectations, motherhood, and the performance of perfection online. (Vogue)

In other words:

Natalie Heller Mills is not presented as a fictional Hannah Neeleman. She is a character shaped by many real-world conversations and cultural influences.

Similarities Between Yesteryear and Ballerina Farm

Although Burke hasn’t confirmed that Natalie is based on Hannah Neeleman, there are undeniable similarities that explain why readers continue making the comparison.

The important distinction is that shared themes do not necessarily mean direct inspiration.

Many influencers have contributed to the popularity of tradwife content, and Burke has indicated that she drew from the movement as a whole rather than creating a fictional biography of one person. (British Vogue)

Is Yesteryear Based on a True Story?

No.

Yesteryear is a work of fiction.

Its time-travel premise, characters, and plot are entirely fictional. However, like many contemporary novels, it draws inspiration from real cultural conversations.

Rather than telling one person’s story, Burke uses fiction to explore questions many readers are already asking:

• Why do idealized online lives feel so appealing?
• How much of social media is performance?
• Can nostalgia distort our understanding of history?
• What happens when fantasy collides with reality?

These questions resonate because they reflect issues that extend far beyond any single influencer.

Hannah Neeleman’s Response

As the novel gained popularity, Hannah Neeleman was asked about readers’ belief that she inspired Natalie.

She responded calmly, saying she understood why people made the connection and wasn’t surprised by the discussion surrounding the book. Rather than confirming or denying any direct link, she suggested that public figures often become part of broader online conversations and said she generally avoids engaging in internet debates. (dailywire.com)

Her response mirrors Burke’s own comments: both acknowledge the comparison without presenting Yesteryear as a direct retelling of one person’s life.

Why the Comparison Matters

Whether or not Natalie is based on Hannah Neeleman isn’t actually the novel’s most interesting question.

The real strength of Yesteryear lies in its examination of:

• Curated online identities.
• The commercialization of authenticity.
• Romanticized visions of the past.
• Gender expectations.
• Motherhood.
• The pressure to appear perfect.

These themes resonate because they’re much larger than one influencer or one social media account.

That’s also why readers from very different backgrounds often see different real-life figures reflected in Natalie.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

So, is Yesteryear based on Ballerina Farm?

The fairest answer is no—but the comparison isn’t baseless.

Caro Claire Burke has made it clear that she drew inspiration from the wider tradwife movement and the online performance of femininity, not from a single influencer. Hannah Neeleman and Ballerina Farm are undeniably part of that cultural conversation, which explains why readers continue to make the connection.

Approaching the novel this way allows you to appreciate what Yesteryear is really trying to explore: not the life of one internet personality, but the powerful—and sometimes unsettling—stories we tell ourselves about identity, nostalgia, and the image of the “perfect” life. (Vogue)

📚 Explore the Yesteryear Collection

Everything you need to know about Yesteryear—from spoiler-free reviews to in-depth analysis and recommendations.

Buy Yesteryear

If Yesteryear sounds like your kind of read, you can support Pages & Prose by purchasing the book through our Amazon affiliate link at no extra cost to you.

📚 Buy Yesteryear on Amazon and support Pages & Prose through our affiliate link.

Amazon

bookshop

For 0.99$